Tony's N.Y. Pizza Claim this business
About
Tony's N.Y. Pizza is a pizza restaurant located in Marco Island. Rated 4.4 stars from 286 Google reviews.
Services
Send an Inquiry
Contact Tony's N.Y. Pizza directly for quotes or questions.
Is this your business?
Take control of your listing, respond to inquiries, and attract more local customers.
Claim this profileContact Info
- Address145 S Barfield Dr, Marco Island, FL 34145, USA, Marco Island 34145
- Phone(239) 970-0027
- Websitewww.tonysnypizzamarco.com/
- $Pricing$$
Your ad here
Contact us to advertise in this spot
Reviews
This was my first trip and definitely won't be my last! I had the small Ceasar, a garlic knot and slice of margarita pizza and it was all delectable. I wish I'd never met that garlic knot in particular! That will haunt my dreams and put my car on auto-pilot come my next bad day, I'm sure! Omg.... worth every sinful little carb in there! The pizza was the same and, while I couldn't eat it all at lunch, it was the perfect dinner. Reheated wonderfully on my Pizza Pizzazz! Enjoy the journey! ❤️ Indy ~ On a Quest!
You could literally make a doughball out of the barely cooked crust, one bite and the entire toppings and cheese slide off. Definitely not my first thought when someone says New York Style. Had to guess where it was cut to get the actual slice. Two people tried it other two passed.
Great food. We shared a pizza and the meatball appetizer. The small in dinning was full when we ate there at dinner time on a Friday night. The place was busy with take out orders. The staff was friendly and attentive to our needs while eating in. This place is one of our favorites when we visit the island to escape the cold from the Midwest.
Exactly what you expect from a pizza joint. New York memorabilia on the wall, red and white checkered tablecloths and extremely good pizza. When working on this side of the island, we have to come to Tony's. Sometimes we'll come in here 3 days in a row. The cheese is as good as the sauce and they are both as good as the crust. They don't skimp out on the extra cheese, 😎. Best pizza on Marco in my opinion.
This pizza used to be so good, now it's just ok. Ordered a meatball and extra cheese and it was so greasy we had to blot it with paper towel. 7 of them. The crust was super thin and not even, some pieces had crust at the top and some didn't. It really is a shame cause the meatballs were pretty good. I don't know what changed but they are using cheap ingredients and it shows. Today was the last time for a while. Sorry, it's sad.